This essay is telescopic. It can shrink or expand, depending on how much attention you are willing to give.
This is the original version (1300 words). Show other sizes.
I Wandered Through Barren Trees
"That time of year thou mayst in me behold When yellow leaves, or none, or few, do hang Upon those boughs which shake against the cold, Bare ruined choirs, where late the sweet birds sang."
— Shakespeare, Sonnet 73
I wandered through barren trees this morning. January, the Netherlands, that particular grey that isn't quite weather, just a general absence of light. The dog ran ahead. My hands were cold. Nothing happened.
And yet I kept stopping, because I could see things I can't see in July.
In summer, a wood is a wall. Green on green, leaves over leaves, every sightline closed at ten metres. In winter the same wood becomes a hall of columns. You can see a hundred metres in. You can see the shape of the land underneath — a dip here, an old ditch there, the way the ground tilts toward water. You can see the birds' nests that were invisible all summer, hanging in the crooks like forgotten hats. You can see which branches are dead, which two limbs are rubbing each other raw, where the lightning went in.
Winter is when the structure shows.
Why gardeners prune in January
Any orchardist will tell you: you prune in the dormant season. There are two reasons, and both are instructive.
The first is practical. A dormant tree isn't running sap. Cut it in June and it bleeds, it panics, it throws out a dozen water sprouts in the wrong direction. Cut it in January and it simply accepts the cut and reorganises in spring around the new shape you gave it.
The second reason is epistemic. In summer you cannot see what you are cutting. The foliage hides the architecture. You'd be guessing. In winter the whole logic of the tree is visible — the leader, the scaffolds, the crossing branches, the dense inner clutter that will never get light. You can only make good cuts when the thing is naked.
I think about this a lot in relation to work, and lately in relation to the machines we're building.
Because we have abolished winter.
Perpetual summer
Not the meteorological one — give us time, we're working on that too. I mean the operational one.
There was a time when most human systems had a dormant season built into them. Fields lay fallow — the medieval three-field rotation deliberately idled a third of all arable land every year, not out of poverty but out of knowledge. Shops closed. Letters took weeks. Ships waited for wind. Debts were periodically erased in jubilee years. Whole cultures had a Sabbath, which is a weekly miniature winter: a hard stop, non-negotiable, when production is forbidden.
None of these were efficient. All of them were adaptive.
Today almost nothing in my life goes dormant. The inbox doesn't have a season. The feed is in continuous leaf. The company's quarterly rhythm is just four summers in a row. And now the most interesting machine ever built sits in my pocket in a state of permanent, cheerful, instantaneous spring: ask it anything at three in the morning and it will bloom for you, no chilling required.
That last bit is the part I want to dwell on.
The chilling requirement
Here is a fact from pomology that I find almost unbearably beautiful.
Many temperate fruit trees — apple, cherry, peach, pistachio — will not flower properly unless they first accumulate enough hours of cold. It's called the chilling requirement, and it's measured in chill hours: time spent between roughly 0°C and 7°C. An apple cultivar might need eight hundred to a thousand of them. The cold isn't something the tree survives. It's something the tree needs. The buds are chemically locked, and only sustained cold turns the key.
Deprive a cherry tree of its winter and it doesn't become more productive. It becomes erratic. The buds open at random, the flowering is scattered over weeks instead of synchronised into a single fertile week, the pollinators miss the window, and the harvest fails. Growers in warming regions are already living this. California pistachio farmers have had catastrophic years not from drought or frost but from winters that were too mild.
A warm winter is not a gift. It is a failed winter.
So the question that followed me home through the bare trees was: what is my chilling requirement? What in me is bud-locked, waiting for a cold period that I keep cancelling?
I suspect quite a lot. The ideas that matter to me have never arrived during productive periods. They arrive after a stretch of apparent nothing — a long illness, a boring commute, a week in a place with no signal, the three days after finishing something big when I feel hollowed out and useless. Something gets consolidated in the dark. The same way sleep doesn't just rest the brain but actively prunes synapses and files memories — forgetting as an active, expensive, essential process, not a failure of storage.
We have known this forever and we keep forgetting it, which is ironic, given that forgetting is the point.
Machines that never sleep
Now consider the thing we've built.
A large language model has no winter. It has no dormant season, no chill hours, no shedding. Its training ended; after that it is in full, fixed leaf, permanently June. Each conversation begins at zero and ends at zero. There is no night in which the day's experience is consolidated, no cold period in which the useless is pruned, no autumn in which the expensive solar collectors are deliberately dropped because the light has gone thin.
This is usually described as a limitation of memory. I think it's better described as a missing season.
And the real risk isn't to the machine. The machine doesn't care. The risk is to us, because we are entraining to its rhythm. If your collaborator is available at every hour in identical condition, never tired, never fallow, never in a trough, then your own troughs start to feel like malfunctions. You stop reading them as winter and start reading them as failure. You take the warm-winter option. You keep the leaves on.
And then, in spring, nothing flowers properly.
Bare, not barren
So here is a small design brief, for ourselves and eventually for our machines:
Build winter in. Not as recovery — recovery is just a repair shop for summer. As a distinct phase with its own work. Set a season where you don't produce, where instead you can finally see the structure of what you've built, and where you cut. Make the cuts in the cold, when the thing isn't bleeding and you can see what you're doing.
Allow forgetting. Any system that only accumulates becomes dense, shaded, and fruitless at the centre. The job of the gardener isn't only to grow. As I've written elsewhere in a Creative Gardener's Job Description: your job is to love winter.
Distrust the mild. A life with no cold period is not a life of abundance. It's a life of scattered, unsynchronised, unpollinated blossom.
One last thing. I called them barren trees in the title because that's the phrase that arrived, but it's the wrong word, and the wrongness is the whole essay.
Barren means unable to bear. Sterile. Finished.
Bare means showing you itself, with nothing in the way.
The trees I wandered through this morning were not barren. Under the ground their roots were still growing — roots keep working in cold soil long after the canopy has shut down. In every bud, a chemical clock was counting cold hours toward a threshold. Nothing visible was happening and everything necessary was happening.
They were naked, and they were busy.
I should be so lucky.
Original published: November 16, 2026